Disney’s Aulani vs. Hilton Hawaiian Village

We had the amazing opportunity of getting to stay at these two gems in Hawaiian family fun! Both resorts are highly revered by families with little and big ones alike because of its diversity in venues, array of amenities for all ages, and the convenience that each of these mega resorts provide to cater to all.

So how did they stack up against each other and which one is better for you and yours?

Aulani, a Disney Resort & Spa

Disney's Oahu based property, is everything you expect from a Disney hotel - and not just one in Hawaii.  Aulani is located in Ko Olina, just west of the airport and heading into a drier, more industrial part of the island.  But the resort area of Ko Olina is also home to a variety of high end properties for vacation goers looking to escape the traffic of Waikiki. And driving up to it, Aulani is everything you'd expect from Disney magic.   

On arrival, you're greeted with infused waters and fresh flower leis for women, kukui nut for men and kids receive Menehune necklaces, which are the famed characters of Hawaiian folklore that "lurk" around property.  While you're on property, you're welcomed "home" as Aulani does sit as part of the Disney Vacation Club portfolio - and they even have designated showrooms to showcase with anyone interested in learning more about becoming a member. For us regular guests, being welcomed home was definitely just a nice touch to make us feel even more welcome here!  

The resort is very accessible with two towers connected by the main entry building, where you can find shops and the flagship restaurant offering character dining.  Walking through the lobby, you can head outside to the lanai and get a full glorious view  of the resort.  And you'll see that once you're here, you're here - restaurants line both sides of of the property, the pools are centrally situated with the beach in the horizon, and the parking garage and main roads out of sight, so you really have no reason to head back to your car! 

We booked an entry level room - garden pool view and were granted a low floor request we made.  This was perfect because we ended up being situated right by the lazy river.  And with a separate patio entrance that led out to the pool area, we enjoyed our easy accessibility to the fun at this resort, especially since we were going to be spending ALL of our time here!

When we booked our trip to Hawaii, we knew we'd want to stay a few days at Aulani on our pursuit of visiting as many Disney properties worldwide!  The per night cost became a matter of how much time we spent here, because we didn't want to lose any time away, but rather enjoy what we paid for.  Disney's price is steep in comparison to other properties in Hawaii, especially if you plan to spend most of your time exploring the island.  But when you compare the cost of Aulani to other Disney resorts, you'll see that their Hawaiian sister hotel is priced no higher than staying at some of the premier Disney properties all over the world. 

So what does the price include, outside of room?

• Access to all pool, beach & recreation, including use of lounge chairs on the beach.
• A daily wristband at the towel stand that will give you fresh towels at the pool & access to the amenities.
• The age 3-12 kids club at Aunty's Beach House - open daily from 8a-6p (hours can vary).  Each child registered for Aunty's receives a MagicBand on arrival to identify them, and parents are loaded up with a ton of security measures to ensure they know their child's safety there. You will be charged for MagicBand, but its fully refundable on return (just like the Disney Cruise Line). 
• Activities around property including character meet and greets, the Menehune Adventure Trail game, live entertainment, Mo'Olelo Fire Pit Storytelling, 'Ohana Disney Move nights, and in room DVD rentals from the Pau Hana Community Room.

The price does not include: 

• Parking (there are self and valet options, both at $37)
• Meals or drinks (not an all-inclusive resort)
• Some activities including those limited in attendance - fitness classes, luau, workshops, snorkeling and other excursions. 
• After hours childcare, including special activities and full meals at Aunty's House 

Other things to note:

• Disney does have pay-per-use laundry rooms on site.  We stayed on the first floor with a laundry room down the hall from our location, equipped with about 5 washers and dryers.   The room was quiet and you could not hear it from anywhere in the hall, but  made all the difference to know we had it there.  You could even purchase single use detergent and dryer sheets in the laundry room in case you wanted to reuse some of your wardrobe. 
• Disney does have a luau on-site, but it does not run every night (only Tuesday - Saturday).  It is a nominal cost per person cost and space is limited. If you prefer a different luau option, Paradise Cove is a luau next door (about a 10 minute walk away) and a highly regarded option in Oahu! 
• Once you check in, everything can be billed back to your room key - a wonderful convenience for staying put on property. 
• There is a shopping plaza across the street with some other dining/shopping options AND all the other Ko Olina resorts are within walking distance.  Though we did not check out other options during our time there, we liked that we had the opportunity to explore without having to leave property by car.  

Hilton Hawaiian Village

Location, location, location!

I think the one thing that could sell this place alone is location. Not only is it centrally located in Honolulu but it also is quite honestly the only resort on Waikiki with prime beach access.  This is where you want to stay if you want to be in the hustle and bustle of the city of Honolulu, but not on busy Waikiki itself.  The resort is closer to the marina, but from the beach you have postcard views of Diamond Head in the distance. 

On arrival, you drive through the Rainbow Bazaar, a small through street with a marketplace of shops and restaurants on either side.  You pull up to the open air lobby building where you can leave the car on idle while you get yourself checked in.  They aren't greeting you with the leis like Disney did on arrival, but the guest service was just as superb.  Once checked in, you're given a full map of the property, which is lined by 8 towers, 5 pools, and various shops and restaurants (even beyond the Bazaar).  Like Aluani, parking is not include - you have the option of valet for $52/daily or self park at $45/daily. If you opt to self park, the garage is back at the entrance to the Bazaar and once you're situated, you do have in/out privileges. 

The resort feels and is massive! And is only matched with the number of people you see everywhere.  It's definitely a different vibe than the "quieter" Aulani as there is a lot of movement here - but it only makes you want to get in on the action.  The lobby really is the central point to the resort, but there isn't a spot that grants you an overall view of the resort.  Each tower is like a world in itself, each with its own pool, bar, restaurant - but best of all, you have full access to the whole village while you're here!  Beyond the Rainbow Tower, you will find the strip of beach that is designed for Hilton guests - though the chairs do come at an extra cost to rent for the day.  Also good to note, all beaches are public and aren't just limited to hotel guests (same goes for Aulani).  Next to the beach is the manmade lagoon for someone wanting the feel of the ocean but with the calmness of a pool - this is also home to water activities like paddle boarding and paddle boat rentals.  

We booked a room without a particular request here, but they upgraded us to a high floor and view of the water.  This was a nice change of pace since there really isn't a ground floor room option, and with the sheer magnitude of this resort, I'm not sure I'd want to be so close to the noise.  Our room was generous in size, larger than Disney's with room to spare - but the bathroom could have used more square footage to make it easier for a family to utilize! 

For this leg of the trip in Hawaii, we wanted to book a place that we could come back to and enjoy but also not feel burdened leaving for the price, as we wanted to see the rest of the island! The price point here made that comfortable to do.  We considered other options but all lacked the proximity to the beach we wanted - so we fell for the idea that this was a great resort for the family to relax at after a busy day out.  And it really is - there's so much to do & was a great place to wind down at after full days! And on top of that, its in Honolulu - so if your list of things to do include checking off spots on Waikiki, you're right here!  Leave the car behind and go for a walk to discover what the city has to offer - that's what we did! 

So what does the price include, outside of room?

• Access to all pool, beach & recreation (but it does come as an additional resort charge) 
• Daily fresh towels at the pool (though no wristband needed); the towels are also handed out in exchange for a towel key.  Towel key must be returned at your end of stay to not be charged $10 per towel on departure. 
• Activities around property including movies by the pool, DVD rentals (boxes conveniently located  at base of each tower), torch lighting ceremonies, and fireworks on Friday night. 

The price does not include: 

• Parking (as noted, valet and self available)
• Meals or drinks (not an all-inclusive)
• Some activities including those limited in attendance - fitness classes, luau (there is on-site as well as several other in Waikiki), workshops and water activities. 
• Camp Penguin Kids Program for age 5 to 12 - though we didn't get to check it out here.  We knew our days would be filled with time together so we didn't even explore.  But to know the option exists is great - only down side is that it is additional. 

Other things to note:

• Hilton did not have a laundry room for guest use - they did have laundry bags but prices were pretty high.  Pack extra if you're staying here and don't want to pay the price of dry cleaning!  
• Hilton does have a luau on-site, located via the parking garage.  It is an additional cost and if you prefer a different more authentic options, there are other luaus in and around Honolulu to enjoy!  
• Once you check in, almost everything can be billed back to your room key - we ran into a few instances where they needed to reverify we were part of the resort.  So beyond the extra security measure of calling up the front desk to ensure we were guests, it would have been easier to just pay by credit card then have to go through a process. 
• There are plenty of other things to do in the area that is waking distance, including a Waikiki historical trail or chartering one of many activities sold right on the beach.  This is a great place to be if you want to do more with your vacation!   

Which One’s for You?

We wanted to start our vacation on a lighter more relaxing note to catch up with the time change, so we enjoyed all we could out of Aulani.  But we definitely would not have stayed here if we were leaving to go sightseeing - unless we were DVC members or got an unbelievable price per night.  We enjoyed two nights to settle in and get some R&R before our adventure started. It is also not conveniently located to much on the island beyond the North Shore. You may avoid the traffic of Honolulu (which was not that bad), but you would be driving a little farther because of where it is situated. Stay here if you plan to stay PUT here. And if you're even toying with the idea of staying here, do it for at least a few days of your trip.  It's definitely a place to visit and you won't regret it - we loved our times to unwind with Disney magic before we visited the beauty of Hawaii!

Hilton Hawaiian Village felt like great place to leave and come back go to. It was a great resort, but I could not imagine spending all my days here just because of the sheer magnitude of the resort. It was a nice place to retreat to after days of fun because we were still able to take in all the amenities without feeling like we missed out, because it did lack some of the magic Disney has. And the price made it even easier to leave - since it was at half the cost of what we paid at Disney. If you want a prime place on Waikiki beach, with ground level pools and a village all its own, this is the place for you! It was a nice way to get wrapped into what Honolulu had to offer and not feel like we were missing out on any magic - because we made what we wanted out of our days when we returned!

Either way you can’t go wrong! But it’s all a matter of what you want from your time in paradise!

Still undecided? Check out our Highlights on Instagram for more information about our time at either resort!